StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Are Humans the Only Animals with Theory of Mind - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "Are Humans the Only Animals with Theory of Mind" discusses certain animals that possess conceptual representations and many more complex kinds of behavior are also noted in the animal kingdom based on cognitive information processing…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.9% of users find it useful
Are Humans the Only Animals with Theory of Mind
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Are Humans the Only Animals with Theory of Mind"

Download file to see previous pages

Even though Bead seems to be right in giving the above statements, yet, it is contradicted by the “Cognitivist” view in certain aspects. Firstly, the Cognitivist view states that non-human animals already possess beliefs, concepts, etc. Secondly, primatologists claim that apes have a “Theory of mind”, they are self-conscious and they can learn some basics of language even1. There are certain theorists who claim that since humans have evolved from apes, humans have more of what apes already possess.

Since beliefs, concepts, etc are already possessed by apes, humans have more of these, as per evolutionary evidence. Other theorists, however, claim that there is a sharp discontinuity between apes and humans. They state that humans possess certain cognitive abilities which apes do not, like “language instinct” or “higher-order representations”2. Though this theory reveals some noticeable differences between apes and us, it could not establish the evolutionary basis of how such differences arose.

Mead has stated that animals cannot take the position of the other; when such statements are made or such questions are raised it is to be kept in mind that we are dealing with animal consciousness or experience. Making such statements is not quite acceptable because we really do not know what other animals actually experience. Here, first, we should question ourselves, if at all we have the complete competency to study the animal mind. We do not know what it is like to be an elephant, a bat, or a whale because we are not those; however, we can say that maybe we know what it is like to be a mammal.

Theories, so far have mainly focused on higher cognitive capabilities, using linguistics and computer-based models. The more basic cognitive tasks which we share with other animals are not yet being researched in detail 3. Fred Dretske suggests an example: certain birds avoid eating Monarch butterflies since they cannot be digested by them. These birds are also intelligent enough to even avoid those butterflies which mimic Monarch in appearance. These birds must have interpreted something internally in their mind, a manifestation of which is clearly evident in their actions or behaviors.

This is sufficient proof to claim that birds have beliefs and concepts4. Irene Pepperberg conducted a certain experiment with a bird named Alex, the findings of which are most interesting. The experiment was about match-to-sample and non-match-to-sample. The aim of the experiment was specifically to know if Alex could give the right response not only to definite patterns, and properties of stimuli; but also to categories; for example, not only recognizing what is ‘green’ or not but also recognizing the relation amid a green pen and a blade of grass.

The bird was well trained to give correct answers to queries like ‘What color?’ , ‘What shape?’; by alternating these questions with ‘What’s this?’ etc. However, focus on the test objects was avoided because it would not give the right inference about whether the response of the bird is based on stimuli-governed conditioning or by its conceptual representation. Results revealed that the animal was capable of dealing with an orderly object-property-representation which forms the core basis for any conceptual representation5.

 

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Are human the only animals with theory of mind Essay”, n.d.)
Are human the only animals with theory of mind Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/psychology/1493109-are-human-the-only-animals-with-theory-of-mind
(Are Human the Only Animals With Theory of Mind Essay)
Are Human the Only Animals With Theory of Mind Essay. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1493109-are-human-the-only-animals-with-theory-of-mind.
“Are Human the Only Animals With Theory of Mind Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1493109-are-human-the-only-animals-with-theory-of-mind.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Are Humans the Only Animals with Theory of Mind

Applying Human Rights Theory in Defense of Animal Rights

The rhetoric of animal rights protection has often been dismissed as first-world, middle-class rhetoric, invocations of those who live in conditions where human beings are not confronted daily by mind-numbing realities of gnawing hunger, poverty, and marginalization.... This paper "Applying Human Rights theory in Defense of Animal Rights" argues the anthropocentric approach to justice is not repugnant to basic principles of rights.... Modern theories of rights that seek to apply 'human rights' standards to animals are in fact simply new articulations of old ideas....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

What are the key differences between human speech and other animal vocal communication systems

he Game theory,an analysis of the animal vocal communication studies,includes data and descriptions that analyze the frequency dependence of animal vocal communications in a given or observed setting.... The Game theory, an analysis of the animal vocal communication studies, includes data and descriptions that analyze the frequency dependence of animal vocal communications in a given or observed setting.... The Game theory reveals or delves into the data research that an animal's behavior – including their vocal communication systems – depends upon the frequency in which the animal appears and/or is present within the animal's setting, environment or population....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

The Ethics of Eating Animals

The purpose of this research "The Ethics of Eating animals" is to shed the light on the ethical problems in eating animal meat.... The writer suggests that animals are equally intelligent and should be considered if not given equal treatment as human beings in food consumption.... Today many people are likely to eat anything edible without regard to whether it came from the lab, from animals or grown as plants.... To understand the justification for the annihilation of animals based on their lack of intelligence and feeling, consider the treatment of two domestic animals a dog and a sheep....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Ethical Exploration of Animal Rights

Wise claims that animals should not have rights because 'it lacks that quality of mind that matters for legal rights.... One of the most debated topics in modern animal rights discourses is whether animals should be used for scientific tests or not.... Considerate people opine that animals can be used in scientific experiments if such experiments are meant for the betterment of humanity and the animal kingdom.... Some of those who are against animal testing argue about animals possess consciousness....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Issues Facing the Animal Society in the Todays World

This essay "Issues Facing the Animal Society in the Today's World" discusses animal rights which establish what is termed as a philosophical stand for the human rights, just as is put clear in Reagan's theory where he considers life as the body of integrity and argues that it is to be protected.... The theory further argues in the study by Tuskegee that the liberty of individual beings has to be protected.... The moral theory extends this same protection to all sorts of life forms out in the globe....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Sociology: Humans and Other Animals

harles Darwin and his theory of evolution, also which could have been used as a contribution towards challenging these ideas, did not change peoples attitudes towards animals.... Anthrozoology or the relationship between humans and animals had not been a very deeply researched arena, because of the Cartesian theory that only humans are capable of forming and sustaining close relationships (Arluke and Sanders, 1996).... (Thomas, 1983:34) This was further neglected due to the anthropocentric and/or utilitarian theory that held the view that animals are the means to an end in the universal chain where humans stand at the top (Taylor, 2007, a & b)....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

The Animal Welfare Act 2006

But even with such provisions, there were some factors that this guy, Robbie, took for granted in taking care of these animals.... Veterinarians) to find out how to take proper care of animals.... The paper 'The Animal Welfare Act 2006' deals with the issue of animal welfare, animal rights, and ethics....
14 Pages (3500 words) Case Study

Are Animals Conscious

One does not have to enter the animal mind to investigate its self-awareness, yet the behaviors of the animal reveal much more than is needed as proof.... This paper asserts that much as animals do not possess the intelligence of a human being, they are conscious and may express behaviors that exhibit self-awareness and understanding of self.... It is illogical to assume that animals lack consciousness because they cannot communicate with humans using the same verbal language....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us