StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Divine Command Theory - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author examines the divine command theory which shows only one spectrum of the ethical theories in Christian faith. Despite the many problems stemming from its arguments, atheist or believer finds fervor in defending the divine command theory in view of God’s sovereignty.  …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.5% of users find it useful
The Divine Command Theory
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Divine Command Theory"

The Divine Command Theory The term divine command theory refers to the ramification of related ethical theories which hold that God's will is the foundation of ethics. Such theory entails that the moral value of acts, i.e. their "goodness" or "badness," is dependent only on God's commands ("Divine Commands and Morality"). There are three main versions of the theory which are summarized as the weakest, stronger and strongest versions. The weakest version argues that God's commands are applicable within the context of specific religious communities, thus, limiting the application to only those within a specific group or sect.

The stronger version holds that moral behavior is good in itself, as such, we should live in a particular manner since God wills it. Similar to the weakest version, this entails the only religious believers need to concern themselves with moral accountability. The strongest version asserts that moral behavior is good because it is willed by God. ("Faithnet") The divine command theory is said to have been disproved by the Euthyphro dilemma, dubbed after Plato's dialogue, which goes: "Are morally good acts willed by God because they are morally good, or are they morally good because they are willed by God" ("Philosophy of Religion") If one accepts the first argument that morally good acts are willed by God because they are morally good, the independence problem arises.

This means that the argument itself is inconsistent with the theory since moral value becomes independent from God's will. ("Philosophy of Religion") On the other hand, should one hold the second argument that morally good acts become such because they are willed by God, then problems pertaining to arbitrariness, emptiness and repugnant commands are contended with. The arbitrariness problem stems from the argument that the divine command theory seems to attribute morality only on God's whims.

The emptiness problem implies that statements depicting God as good do not make sense, thereby, rendered as empty tautologies. Given the divine command theory, God can only be described as consistent because God acts in accordance with his command. Lastly, the problems of abhorrent commands result from the divine command theory because it seems to entail that if God willed abhorrent acts like murder and rape, these acts would become morally good. ("Philosophy of Religion") In response to the critiques of this theory, some religious writers like William of Ockham reacts with his firm belief that God could change the moral order at any time and disregards the above objections.

Others recognize the need to address the said problems. For instance, Duns Scotus argues that, given one set of moral values, God could not have commanded contrarily because they are necessary. However, some moral values are dependent on God's decision, so God could have commanded otherwise. As an example, it is a necessary truth that murder is morally wrong, therefore, God could not have commanded otherwise or rescinded this command. On the other hand, keeping the Sabbath Day holy or going to church every Sunday is not a necessary truth, in this regard, God could have commanded otherwise or retracted this command.

("Wikipedia") Similarly, Philip Quinn also argues for the acceptance of the divine command theory given the same reasons. Moreover, he asserts that God's sovereignty entails that God must be in control of everything including moral standards. His arguments require total belief in God's exercise of control over creation (Hooker). The divine command theory shows only one spectrum of the ethical theories in Christian faith and probably one of the most debated philosophical issues. Despite the many problems and questions stemming from its arguments, a theist or believer finds fervor in defending the divine command theory in view of God's sovereignty and role as the prime mover and master creator.

ReferencesDivine Commands and Morality, Paul Helm ed., Oxford University Press, 1981.Faithnet. 07 October 2005 Hooker, B. "Cudworth and Quinn." Analysis 61, 2001.Philosophy of Religion. 07 October 2005 Wikipedia. 07 October 2005

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Divine Command Theory Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
The Divine Command Theory Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1528183-the-divine-command-theory-essay
(The Divine Command Theory Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
The Divine Command Theory Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1528183-the-divine-command-theory-essay.
“The Divine Command Theory Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1528183-the-divine-command-theory-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Divine Command Theory

Ethical Dilema on Abortion

And this “right to live” is also supported by the philosophical stance of Immanuel Kant and The Divine Command Theory.... According to Cowan and Spiegel, The Divine Command Theory is able to “provide sufficiently clear moral direction and an adequate sense of duty” (qtd.... When it comes to understanding moral and religious issues, divine command theory is perhaps the best.... hellip; Considering the topic of abortion, it is necessary to understand the utilitarian theory by J....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Ontological Arguments About The Divine Command Theory Of Morality

The paper "Ontological Arguments About The Divine Command Theory Of Morality" discusses The Divine Command Theory of morality based on a number of principles that show a strong conviction and logic against common beliefs and assumed logic and how Plato argues against it.... For this reason, the foundation of morality in the case of The Divine Command Theory of morality, morality becomes an arbitrary issue (Austin).... hellip; The theory of divine command theory of morality loses its sense in that in the first place it sees the gods as arbitrary beings who only seek to justify the behavior, conduct, ethics and morality of humankind....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

What does it mean to act morally

However The Divine Command Theory is inefficient in describing the religion lead morality.... Thus The Divine Command Theory is not an efficient approach for contemporary moral philosophy.... divine command theory is widely used for describing the moral judgments which are made based on religious abstracts.... There are many theories advocated by the psychologists relating to the moral judgment example: Piaget's “genetic Epistemology” and Haidt's “social-intuitionist” theory (Bucciarelli et....
6 Pages (1500 words) Term Paper

FreeWill and Determinism

This means that not all behaviours that we portray are determined.... The humanistic term that is applied to imply the exercise of free will is personal agency.... Personal agency means the choices that… The freedom of the will is affected by various prevailing factors.... These includes metaphysical constraints that includes logical, theological determinism, and nomological....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Religion and morality

The video is an expansion of The Divine Command Theory and Natural Law Theory.... The video is an expansion of The Divine Command Theory and Natural Law Theory.... The Divine Command Theory states that action is ethically right when God orders it or that action is ethically wrong when God prohibits it.... The video points out two key problems with The Divine Command Theory.... As a result, many theologians do not support The Divine Command Theory....
1 Pages (250 words) Coursework

Comparison of the Divine Command Theory and the Natural Law Theory

The essay "Comparison of The Divine Command Theory and the Natural Law Theory" determines the differences between the two.... However, the natural law theory is not at all different from the divine law theory because of the source of the standards of doing what is moral and avoiding what is immoral.... nbsp;Divine law theory, on the other hand, holds ordinances some of which pertain to the order of nature and are thus accessible to natural reason....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Same-Sex Couples in the United States Should not be Legally Permitted to Get Married

In addition, the different theories such as The Divine Command Theory, natural law theory, and utilitarian perspective as discussed above, gay marriages should not be legalized.... Various theories have been presented such as The Divine Command Theory, the utilitarian perspective, and the Natural Law Theory in response to the legalization of same-sex marriage in the United States.... he divine command theory argues that goodness is rooted in God's being and that all He commands is good....
8 Pages (2000 words) Report

Challenges of the Divine Command Theory

The paper "Challenges of The Divine Command Theory" analyzes and discusses the problems associated with divine command theory.... Therefore, divine command theory makes it appear logical.... The paper focuses on the challenges the theory has to contend with by examining in the social and religious contexts to determine the extent to which they limit it.... This theory has in the past and at present provided the basis for volumes of critical works, with philosophers such as Plato and Nielsen having criticized it based on it being forced upon those who do not believe in supreme beings (Nielsen, 1973)....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us