StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

A Fallacy of Ad Hominem - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
In the essay “A Fallacy of Ad Hominem” the author briefly explains the major error in identifying a major fallacy. For example, Brad Pitt is too pretty to be a good actor. Although this is also a fallacy of Ad hominem, this statement is clearly an example of Non sequitur…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.5% of users find it useful
A Fallacy of Ad Hominem
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "A Fallacy of Ad Hominem"

3. Though the proverbial cat is already out of the bag, the codification of such a thing as “animal rights” could potentially lead to consequences that all but the most careless rat-lover would find dire. Certainly if merely gouging a nickel-sized hole in an elephant’s shoulder is the act of a criminal, then hunters should be charged with murder, roadkill is manslaughter, and owning a dog an act of involuntary servitude. Scott McPhersonThis statement commits the slippery slope fallacy, which means that the speaker interprets a simple statement in very general terms and exaggerating it in the process.

The definition of animal rights here is exaggerated and its exceptions are not considered by the speaker in that even benevolent acts like owning a dog, unintentional acts like roadkill, and purposeful acts for the benefit of mankind like hunting are all considered violations of animal rights.4. Both of my friends who went to that University ended up dropping out, so I wouldn’t recommend it. Although this statement also commits the other fallacies of begging the question, non sequitur, and false analogy, it is clearly a hasty generalization.

The claim of the speaker that the particular university is not recommended is obviously not valid for it is based on but two people. There must be a considerable number of students in a sample plus the backing of research before one can make a valid claim that one university cannot be recommended. 5. What do you mean you can’t go because you have to go to mass? Who goes to church anymore? Only old people and the mindless do. This statement is a sweeping generalization. Such a fallacy is committed in this statement because the speaker had already labeled all churchgoers as mindless and old even before the actual disadvantages of going to mass or going to church (if ever there are any) were underlined.6. Considering that Dr.

Burfi weighs about three hundred pounds, should we take his medical advice? Obviously this is a fallacy of Ad hominem. Instead of objectively evaluating the correctness of the medical advice, the speaker goes on to attack the personal weakness of Dr. Burfi.7. President Obama should not have reversed his predecessor’s ruling on stem cell research; President Bush was obviously right on that issue. As far as I know, this statement commits the Red herring fallacy. Instead of the speaker explaining the disadvantages of President Obama’s reversal of President Bush’s ruling on stem cell research, the speaker befogs the issue by tossing out the red herring of his support for President Bush.8. “Uganda's controversial ethics and integrity minister… said Saturday he believed civilization was being threatened by gays.

‘Who is going to occupy Uganda 20 years from now if we all become homosexuals. We know that homosexuals dont reproduce,’ James Nsaba Buturo told a press conference. ’There is now globalization of homosexuality and people in Uganda are attempting to take advantage of the globalization,’ he said. "It is an attempt to end civilization. It is that serious.’" Obviously this is a case of a slippery slope fallacy. First of all, it would be an exaggeration for the speaker to say “if we all become homosexuals” and he further commits the slippery slope as he ultimately concludes that the preceding exaggerated statement would lead to “an attempt to end civilization.

” The speaker should instead have focused on the more local effects of homosexuality based on a relatively smaller scale.9. I know that your tuition fees have risen by 7% since last year, but our University was ranked among the top 10 by The New York Times’ poll in August. This statement obviously commits the red herring fallacy. It means that instead of the speaker evaluating the effects of the 7%-tuition fee increase, he rather tosses out the red herring of the University is one of the top 10 according to The New York Times.10. But you don’t have to be a genius to see the true utility of manufacturing headless creatures… Charles Krauthammer This statement commits the fallacy of the ad.

This means that the speaker thinks that since all people who are not even geniuses (normal people like the reader) can see “the true utility of manufacturing headless creatures,” then it also follows that the reader is supposed to have the same view. However, the speaker does not consider the fact that one’s opinion on the utility of manufacturing headless creatures does not at all depend on whether one is a genius or not.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(A Fallacy of Ad Hominem Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words, n.d.)
A Fallacy of Ad Hominem Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1565836-fallacies-exercise
(A Fallacy of Ad Hominem Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
A Fallacy of Ad Hominem Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1565836-fallacies-exercise.
“A Fallacy of Ad Hominem Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1565836-fallacies-exercise.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF A Fallacy of Ad Hominem

Logical Fallacy in Thinking

ad hominem – Instead of logically arguing, this just attacks the person making the claim.... Attacking the motive – This is like ad hominem.... A logical fallacy is an argument that has some kind of problem with it.... … A logical fallacy is an argument that has some kind of problem with it.... Logical fallacies A logical fallacy is an argument that has some kind of problem with it.... To find a logical fallacy in your own or someone elses thinking the best thing to do is carefully think about the evidence and make sure it really holds the claim up as true....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Fallacious reasoning

The most common fallacies in advertisements are appeal to emotions and ad hominem.... In the ad hominem fallacy, the reasoning attacks the person rather than the issue at hand while in the appeal to emotions, the reasoning manipulates the emotions of the listeners in order to get their emotions (Carey, 2000).... There are many arguments in the world that appear to be sound but critical analyses indicate that they do not conform to logic. Fallacies are very common in commercial Fallacious Reasoning Fallacious Reasoning According to Goldstein, (2005) a fallacy is an argument component that is logically faulty....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

An Amphiboly Is a Tactic to Deceive

Argumentum ad hominem refers to a personal attack to an opponent.... Argumentum ad ignorantium can be used in order to turn the tables on an opponent, shifting the burden of proof to the accuser and not the defender.... This form of fallacy occurs when one attacks the characteristic of an individual, instead of his claims.... ?? The fallacy lies in the neglect of the accusation (Walton).... This form of fallacy occurs in a logical argument, when an individual appeals to the emotions of his audience in order to get them to agree with him, even though this would have no relevance to the argument (Pirie 2006)....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Give each page of a fallacy topic that are related to it

An ad hominem argument is one in which a person attacks the other party rather than addressing the argument and the question itself.... ad hominem is further divided into two categories: abusive and circumstantial.... (Argumentum ad hominem, Web).... This is a fallacy not because people claim that the argument is wrong but because the negative characteristics of people making the argument.... This type of a fallacy is highly common among politicians who, rather than commenting on the issue at hand, try to blame the other party in order to create hype especially among the media....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Use of Fallacy in Media

He may be dismissed on grounds of ad hominem, but sometimes he might be telling the truth.... There are many different types of fallacies; ad hominem is one of them.... He may be dismissed on grounds of ad Discussion Topic A fallacy refers to a flaw in an argument that is more than just a presumption in false assertion.... There are many… This fallacy hinges its arguments on the basis of a person's character or nature (Davis, 2007)....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Defining Various Logical Fallacies

This essay seeks to… fine various logical fallacies that include circular reasoning, ad hominem, Red Herring, pseudo-questions, false cause, sweeping generalizations, slippery slope and equivocation or changing meanings. This is a universal group of fallacies in which an argument is cast off based Philosophy affiliation Introduction A logical error also called a logical fallacy refers to the incorrect reasoning undermines thelogic of an argument.... This essay seeks to define various logical fallacies that include circular reasoning, ad hominem, Red Herring, pseudo-questions, false cause, sweeping generalizations, slippery slope and equivocation or changing meanings....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Logical Fallacies Scavenger Hunt

For if individuals were allowed to commit murder without repercussions, the society obtain a sense of meaning as there would be no order in the world (Duncan 150). This is an example of Simple statement of belief… It suggest to one's belief because when the sentence is analyzed there are no statements raised from it. This is an example of a loosely associated ideas fallacy Further, the fallacy presents two different ideas in a disorganized manner hence making it difficult to understand....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

Fallacy in Everyday Media

A news story by Magnus Linklater of The Times entitled “The age of personal vitriolic abuse” shows vividly how politicians use the fallacy of ad hominem against a political adversary.... Such kind of argument is a classic example of the fallacy of ad hominem because the detractors of Brown did not only criticize his political failures but instead attack his character in order to demerit his stand or his policies.... The author of the paper "Fallacy in Everyday Media" aims to discuss the fallacies of ad hominem, Tu Quoque and Ad Baculum that intentionally evade heading on the issue, thus instead of resolving whatever is actuality upon, it creates another problem....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us