StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Nestle and American Home Products - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Several moral issues arise in the Nestle infant formula developed since 1860s to save the lives of babies whose mothers could not breastfeed due to unavoidable circumstances. Well, Nestle as an entity on its own cannot be realistically separated from its employees and other stakeholders within it. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.6% of users find it useful
Nestle and American Home Products
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Nestle and American Home Products"

? Case Study: Nestle and American Home Products Number Question Several moral issues arise in the Nestle infant formula developed since 1860s to save the lives of babies whose mothers could not breastfeed due to unavoidable circumstances. They include; whether any more information about the nutritive value of the formula was important to mothers; whether the nutritive and hygienic “insufficiencies” in the use of the infant formula as compared to breast milk was a good business was worth emphasizing; whether distributing free infant formula in hospital facilities amounted to unfair inducement of consumers to use the product or it was a normal marketing strategy; and, whether sending salesmen dressed in clinician clothes to distribute free samples of the product amounted to legitimizing the supposedly inferior formula by the clinical fraternity. As Shaw (2010) has noted, consumers have a right to autonomy and informed decisions. In light of these, an attempt to insinuate that the infant formula had the blessings of clinicians and the targeting of soft targets (mothers in hospitals) with free samples was an unfair marketing strategy conceived in bad faith. This is especially true because in Ivory Coast, for example, Nestle increased its free samples of the infant formula to counter the government campaign which was aimed at sensitizing mothers on the benefits of breastfeeding. Although, it is the core policy of business to make profit, it is the moral right of consumers to be furnished with all the necessary information related to a product on sale (infant formula) in order to make informed decisions. Unfortunately, Nestle’s marketing strategy was hell-bent on cashing in on poor, uninformed mothers. Question #2 Well, Nestle as an entity on its own cannot be realistically separated from its employees and other stakeholders within it. Under agency law, Nestle as an organization can be taken to task for violation of moral rules for any inappropriate decision made by its leadership. In light of this, the organization as an entity, but not individual directors and or executives should have the moral responsibility. Question#3 According to Shaw (2010), all corporations all companies are expected to return some of their business gains back to the society as a show of moral responsibility. Nestle and American Home Products (AHP) had exercised corporate social responsibility (CSR) by distributing free samples of infant formula to famine-stricken children and those who could not be breastfed. On the one hand, Nestle and AHP were of the opinion that their free donations of the infant formula did not violate the World Health Organization (WHO) code, which outlaws the distribution of free samples of the product to attract sales. On the other hand, critics such as Action for Corporate Accountability, and Infant Formula Action Coalition (INFACT) pointed out that the body language used by the food processors did not point to any effort aimed at encouraging breastfeeding alongside the use of the infant formula, especially in third-world countries. Nestle’s marketing strategies of enhancing the quantity of free samples of the infant formula to counter breastfeeding campaigns gave it away as an organization that did not care about CSR. This is a classic case of corporate bodies prioritizing their profit-making strategies instead of the moral responsibility, especially where millions of young, innocent lives are in danger. Question #4 Nestle’s CSR as viewed from a narrow perspective depicts the picture of a corporation that had and indeed showed some moral responsibility by saving millions of poor children in third-world countries from famine with its free samples of infant formula. In light of this, the dressing code for Nestle marketers tasked to distribute the product to consumers, and the lack of adequate information on the need to use the product to complement breastfeeding does not seem to attract any qualms. However, a wider perspective of the company’s activities reveals that Nestle used unfair marketing strategies to induce unsuspecting mothers to stop breastfeeding their babies and instead use the infant formula. Additionally, Nestle did not bother to inform such mothers of the need to maintain high hygiene in the use of the infant formula. By stepping up the issuing of free samples of the infant formula in Ivory Coast to counter government support for breastfeeding, Nestle abandoned the corporate responsibility of guaranteeing the society adequate safety (Shaw, 2010). Question # 5 At the inception of the infant formula, Nestle’s conduct seems to be moral in the sense that the product was a favorable option for infants who could not be fed on breast milk. Still, in the 1970s, Nestle’s response to the boycott spearheaded by Dr. Joliffe and INFACT showed high moral responsibility. For instance, the corporation’s assertion that its marketing strategies could not be directly associated with high infant mortality in third-world countries was fairly accurate given that the unhygienic handling of the infant formula during use was to mainly to blame for most of the deaths. The subsequent formation of Nestle Infant Formula Audit Commission (NIFAC) by Nestle was a good gesture aimed at implementing the WHO code internally. Moreover, Nestle was seen to have acted in good faith by publishing regular updates on the implementation of the WHO code. In the end, however, Nestle’s concerted effort to give out more free samples of the infant formula, especially when confronted with stiff breastfeeding campaigns like in Ivory Coast shows that the corporation was reluctant to fully enforce the WHO code, perhaps due to fears of a slump in sales. In light of this, Nestle’s response does not seem to show any sincerity or concern for consumers of infant formula who face health risks by using the product as a substitute rather than a complement for breast milk. Question # 6 Breastfeeding has immense benefits to infants. Therefore, as Shaw (2010) has stated, it is the moral responsibility of corporations to increase the demand for the product for sustainability, provided the consumers and prospects are given adequate information on the shortfalls of using the formula as the sole food for babies. Giving out adequate free samples of the infant formula to prospective customers is moral provided the main intention is not to enhance sales as stated in the WHO code. Nonetheless, there is a thin line between dishing out free samples of a product to enhance sales and carrying out a moral responsibility in the name of CSR. Question #7 Boycotts of products can be fairly successful in ensuring that corporations implement corporate social responsibility (Shaw, 2010). This is especially true for corporations that do not want to be eliminated from the market under low sales will be cowed into submission as was witnessed in the Nestle case. Nonetheless, it is difficult to identify a corporation that exercises CSR with its free product samples to customers and prospects, and one that is on a marketing move. An individual whose life is negatively affected by a corporate product has the moral right to take part in a boycott unless by doing so he or she would be subjected to more suffering. In the Nestle and AHP cases, mothers whose children’s lives are endangered by the use of infant formula may boycott the product only if they had other alternatives, otherwise the affected parties may be starve to death. Reference Shaw, W.H. (2010). Business Ethics: A Textbook With Cases: A Textbook with Cases. New York: Cengage Learning. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Nestle and American Home Products Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Nestle and American Home Products Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/business/1485964-nestle-and-american-home-products
(Nestle and American Home Products Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Nestle and American Home Products Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/business/1485964-nestle-and-american-home-products.
“Nestle and American Home Products Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/business/1485964-nestle-and-american-home-products.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Nestle and American Home Products

Kraft Foods Analysis

Following a series of mergers and acquisitions it today stands as the… Its products include convenient meals, confectionary, cheese, grocery, snacks and beverages (Siegert, 2013). The political environment of North America is quite favourable for It actively supports candidates who draft public policies that are related to the brand and its products.... Better-for-you-products are advertised to children aged between 6 to 11 years.... Kraft Foods has also lowered salt content and fat content from some of its products (Kraft Foods Inc....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Ethical Issues in Branding and Advertising

nestle and Abercrombie and Fitch have both sensationalised and infiltrated the media with targeted and driven advertising and branding… In order to better understand the underlying impetus behind their market and branding strategies, and what this implies for the .... This shift in attention has allowed companies to emotionally manipulate consumers into purchasing products, which they have, little or no real information about, from your morning coffee to the latest piece of throwaway technology....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Event Stategy: Nestle UK

The year 1920 was very remarkable for Nestle because in this year the company ventured into a new arena by launching a new product – chocolate which has ranked second in terms of importance among all the nestle products.... The first business objective of Nestle is the manufacturing and marketing of the Company's products in such a way that it should create a value that can be sustained over a long period of time and it should help the shareholders, employees, consumers and business partners....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Social Performance of Nestle Company

The author of the "Social Performance of nestle Company" paper states thta this company has made changes in society, keeping its focus on the improvement of quality of life, the fulfillment of the nutritional needs of the society, and environmental protection.... nestle is an example or rather a model for other corporations that might wish to be as socially responsible.... nbsp; nestle, is the company that has been involved in social development, mainly in the aspect of environmental well being....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Nestle Company and Its Marketing

Other major brands include Arrowhead and Perrier, baby foods like Gerber, cereals like Cheerios, ice cream including the famed Haagen-Daaz, microwavable food like Hot Pocket and Stouffers, health lines like PowerBar and Jenny Craig products, pet food like Dog Chow and Friskies, and professional food products.... With a few exceptions like Perrier and Haagen-Daaz, Nestle tends to target the lowest common denominator of the market, and most of their products are worldwide household names....
16 Pages (4000 words) Case Study

International Expansion and Its Effects on the Marketing and Product Mix of Nestle

The organization selected for the study is nestle.... nbsp; nestle is the global leader in the food and beverage industry segment and has a significant presence across numerous consumer markets across the globe.... The origins of the company date back to the year 1866 when Henri nestle founded the organization in Vevey Switzerland.... The company's mission is to provide the best quality and highly nutritious food to individuals across the globe (nestle, 2011)     International expansion has given rise to a new term called 'Multinational Corporation'....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

Business Synoptic Module

estle, one of the worlds largest food groups have set out to expand their business in the fast-growing emerging markets which will enable them to make future market growth with the help of new products as well as their existing products (The Economic Times, 2011).... The author identifies whether it makes sense for nestle to focus its growth efforts on emerging markets and examines the company's strategy with regard to business development in emerging markets....
10 Pages (2500 words) Assignment

Corporate Partnerships for Entrepreneurship of Nestle

Global /International marketing is especially important to companies that provide products or services that have a universal demand such as automobiles and food.... estlé deals in a variety of food, health and nutrition products.... Main categories of products include but not limited to Baby Foods, Sports Nutrition, Chocolates, Waters, Coffee, Beverages, Frozen Meals, Ice Cream and Frozen Treats, Imported Foods, Healthcare Nutrition, Pet Foods, and Food services worldwide....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Proposal
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us