StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

What Is Crito Proposing to Socrates and How Does He Try to Justify His Proposal - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author of "What Is Crito Proposing to Socrates and How Does He Try to Justify His Proposal" paper identifies what Socrates holds to be the most important thing, and explains how according to the "Laws" Socrates entered into a tacit contract to obey the state…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.8% of users find it useful
What Is Crito Proposing to Socrates and How Does He Try to Justify His Proposal
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "What Is Crito Proposing to Socrates and How Does He Try to Justify His Proposal"

4. What does Socrates hold to be the most important thing?(48b4-5) To what is it equivalent, according to him? (48b6-7)When Crito delivered the news to Socrates that he will be executed and persuaded him to flee, Socrates told that the most important thing is “that one should value living well rather than merely living” (48b4-5).

He also said that death is nothing compared to injustice (48b6-7)10. How according to the "Laws," did Socrates enter into a tacit contract to obey the state? (51c-53a7)Socrates perceives the “Laws” from the point of gratitude that Athens provided him with a birthplace, and raised and took care of him. He was also educated in Athens and protected himself and his fellow citizens. It is therefore incumbent upon him to obey the state as it raised and took care of him. This tacit contract is enforceable for as long as one stays in Athens.

If one is not amenable to following the laws of Athens or the state, one is free to leave Athens and go somewhere else. But if they chose to stay, they must submit to the laws of the state. The Laws, as Socrates already suggested, have given him birth, have raised him and educated him, and have shared the wealth of Athens with him and his fellow citizens and if they do not like what they see, they are free to take their property and go wherever they please. However, if they choose to stay in Athens, they are actively submitting themselves to the Laws of Athens and must abide by them no matter what.

 This question should be one page long1. Now that you see what Socrates meant by the descriptor “gadfly” name two historical figures whose lives you believe share the characteristics of the Socratic gadfly. Why do you think they can be considered gadflies? (as a point of reference: Socrates calls himself a gadfly in 30e.)Gadfly is a harsh critic of the status quo who is already contented with how things are done even if they are in slumber. The term used in one of the most inflammatory arguments in the Apology was when Socrates described himself as a gadfly who is stinging a lazy horse which is a state.

The personalities I can think of in history that are appropriate to be called a gadfly are Luther Martin Luther King and Rosa Parks. Martin Luther King is a gadfly because he went against the status quo of discrimination and removed the injustice against African American. Rosa Parks on the other hand went against the patriarchal society and asserted the equal rights of women. Name one contemporary person who your children might name as a “historical gadfly” when they take Intro to Philosophy in 25 years.

Barack Obama with his ending of discrimination against BlacksNelson Mandela for ending apartheid. What distinguishes a “gadfly” from a person who is just a “pain in the neck”?Gadfly is a critique of the status quo and works to change it for the better. Pain in the neck is just a whiner who only wants attention.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Question Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Question Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1631894-question
(Question Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Question Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1631894-question.
“Question Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1631894-question.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF What Is Crito Proposing to Socrates and How Does He Try to Justify His Proposal

Crito a Good Friend of Socrates

While waiting for the ship to arrive at Athens and for his death, Socrates' old friend came to try to save him by convincing him to break out of prison.... Socrates believes that one is ought to live a just life, and in order to live a just life, one must do right and must not do what is not right and that it is not right to do wrong, and that laws are just.... In order to live right and just, one must do what is right and must not do what is not right....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Socrates

On the other hand, socrates and Cicero imposed different arguments to provide an understanding on the subject of justice.... On the other hand, socrates and Cicero imposed different arguments to provide an understanding on the subject of justice.... socrates and Cicero both stated that justice was a key virtue in the society.... socrates and Cicero both believed that justice dealt with an idea of fairness.... Generally, socrates and Cicero acknowledged that the laws served interests of the people and they did not subjugate to desires of the prominent leaders of demos or populi Roma (Cicero, 35; Jowett, 15)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Socrates and His Trial

This paper ''socrates and His Trial'' tells that Socrates was a Greek philosopher who lived during the periods of 469 BC to 399 BC when he faced his death after facing a death sentence because of his actions.... However, most of the knowledge and teachings from Socrates are available to modern-day readers from the dialogues that he held with his famous pupil, by the name Plato, who lived in the periods of 427 BC to 347 BC.... Historical records describe Socrates as an individual who neglected his personal affairs to spend much of his time discussing several concepts, which include piety, justice as well as virtue....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Socrates and His Friendship with Crito

The paper "socrates and His Friendship with Crito" discusses that the actions of Crito were totally selfless.... This statement would have us believe that Crito was not really interested in the philosophy of socrates and thus does not qualify as a friend at all.... Crito's concern for his friend has however been proved beyond doubt by his subsequent questions to socrates.... his inability to completely understand the philosophy of his friend should not be held against him since such instances are very rare where two friends are of the same intellectual level....
1 Pages (250 words) Research Paper

Socrates' Argument Against Crito

His appeals to socrates are emotive and suggest that Socrates should consider his own life as greater than reason and logic.... Crito blames himself for not doing more to save his friend, but he is motivated more by what others will think because he has not spent enough money to keep his friend safe.... Socrates losing his children and his seeming cowardice are raised by Crito in this attempt at persuasion, while the possibility of leaving, facilitated by Crito's connections, is highlighted to tempt Socrates....
17 Pages (4250 words) Dissertation

Socrates and His Submission to Law

A friend offers to help him escape the prison but he chooses not to try to escape because he respects the law.... The essay "socrates and His Submission to Law" focuses on the critical analysis of why Socrates submitted to the law despite being innocent and it will seek to prove that Socrates' love for his religion was far above his willingness to cooperate with the laws of Athens.... Socrates was a religious man and was ready to undergo anything to defend his religion....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Socrates Argument in the Crito

What followed and transpired between socrates and Crito was a meaningful dialogue where the latter convinced the former that an escape from prison would be the best solution.... Lastly, Crito emphasized the idea of the importance of posterity to socrates.... According to socrates, '.... The philosopher, however, through a Socratic dialogue, reiterated his refusal to escape because he believed that a morally upright life would be better than mere survival....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Socrates: Biography, Philosophy, and Objections

and lead the thoughts towards what is ethical and true (Cohen, 46).... Although quite little is known about his earlier life.... Part of his biography was recorded by his students among whom included Plato, another Greek philosopher.... Whereas some contemporaries point out that he got paid for teaching philosophy, others like Plato points out Socrates did not accept any payment, citing his poor status as proof of lack of payment....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us