StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Discourse of Meritocracy - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Discourse of Meritocracy" argues that every society is characterized by divisions based on class. The name class has many definitions for various schools of thought; the economists define it in terms of power and control while the sociologists would base it on occupational differences…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.7% of users find it useful
Discourse of Meritocracy
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Discourse of Meritocracy"

For Marx, class divisions were inevitable in society due to the nature of capitalism which divided people into capitalists and proletarians with the class owning the means of production dominating the others and its ideas (ruling class ideas) are the dominant or universal ideas (Morrison, 1995). As such, the dominant class ideas are legitimized and universal thus masking any class differences.

Social inequalities in society are enhanced by differences in wealth, power, and prestige. Despite being a highly stratified society, Australia boasts of having an egalitarian society where equal opportunity for all is encouraged especially through the education system. The question is, does education really bring about social equality or does it serve to reproduce inequalities in society? The idea of education resulting in inequality is based on the discourse of meritocracy whereby inequality is determined by one's ability (Van Krieken, 2010). Education in this case is supposed to play a crucial role in eliminating social inequality through the provision of universal primary and secondary education. All are accorded the opportunity to climb up the social ladder but since the individuals have different abilities, the outcomes of education are different resulting in inequalities, that is, “those who get ahead do so based on own merit” (Carl, 2012: 47).

If all people are accorded equal education opportunities regardless of race or gender or socioeconomic classes, why do social inequalities still exist? The principle of meritocracy just serves to mask the impact of social class on educational achievement. Though functionalists would argue that some positions are important and thus higher rewards must be given to attract potential workers, how is this level of importance determined? Why is a doctor more valued than a teacher or a soldier yet their services are essential? This goes to prove that education just reproduces social inequalities. Though individuals from different backgrounds attend the same schools, their experiences are different thus affecting their educational achievements (Moore, 2004).

According to the protestant work ethic, individuals should work hard for better rewards in the future (Weber 1976 [1930]) thus a person’s identity is defined by the work they do and not what they are. However, Carl (2012) and Van Krieken (2010) note that many other factors are in play in affecting education achievement. First, people from the middle class already have an advantage over the working class before entering higher education. They are socialized to become professionals and are provided with the materials needed to achieve this since childhood. Those from the working class attend public primary schools hence disadvantaged. Furthermore, children from wealthy families are well connected in the labor market thus getting employment more easily widening social inequalities. According to conflict theorists, therefore, stratification is not inevitable since the “system rewards individuals based on where they start and notability” (Carl 2012: 48). In other words, class determines who gets what even in terms of education.

The nature of the education curriculum also serves to sustain inequalities. For structural functionalists, education is “a means of selecting, sorting, and assigning individuals into different places within the economy” (Van Krieken 2010: 173). Students thus take different subjects which may be influenced by social class thus affecting their achievements. Besides, some pupils judge themselves according to how other people view them and this may affect education. For example, if the teacher believes children from the working class are not achievers they may concentrate more on middle-class children thus affecting education outcomes. As Paul Willis in his study observed, some consequences are unintended not planned (Van Krieken, 2010: 182). Meritocracy thus just serves to legitimate further inequalities by masking the effects of social class on educational achievement. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“4 questions to answer, which questions word limit is 600 words, making Assignment”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1612090-4-questions-to-answer-which-questions-word-limit-is-600-words-making-a-total-of-2400-words-the-questions-would-be-upload-later
(4 Questions to Answer, Which Questions Word Limit Is 600 Words, Making Assignment)
https://studentshare.org/sociology/1612090-4-questions-to-answer-which-questions-word-limit-is-600-words-making-a-total-of-2400-words-the-questions-would-be-upload-later.
“4 Questions to Answer, Which Questions Word Limit Is 600 Words, Making Assignment”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1612090-4-questions-to-answer-which-questions-word-limit-is-600-words-making-a-total-of-2400-words-the-questions-would-be-upload-later.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Discourse of Meritocracy

Critical Reading Reflection of the Book Lives on the Boundary

CRITICAL READING REFLECTION OF THE BOOK LIVES ON THE BOUNDARY Introduction This essay will discuss the issues dealt with in the book Lives on the Boundary by Mike Rose and will include some direct references to Mike Rose's story, and the stories of his students.... ... ... ... There will also be a critical reflection about my own experiences that connect to the themes in Rose's text, focussing on some of my experiences in school and in my family....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

HRM and Culture

The mini case, Crack in Particularly Thick Glass Ceiling concerns the plight of women who have had to work in a male-dominated country which is South Korea.... One of the women featured in the cases is Choi Dong Hee who was assimilated in SK's research department in 2005.... ... ... ... Hee was the only woman in the organisation and did not have major assignments being issued to her....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Post War Education Policy in the United Kingdom

Since meritocracy presupposes that boundless opportunities for success exist for all regardless of class, color, ethnicity, and gender, many perceive meritocracy as an ideal justice principle.... The paper "Post War Education Policy in the United Kingdom" tells that To delimit the topic for better focus and grasp, the policy review centers on the British Nationality Act 1948 (BNA) and the Education Act 1944 (EA) structured into a brief introduction, purpose, perspectives, impact....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

MIDTERM PART 1

We find that our meritocracy has served us well; allowing as doing amazing things, would a meritocracy work for you?... We find that our meritocracy has served us well; allowing as doing amazing things, would a meritocracy work for you?...
2 Pages (500 words) Term Paper

Black Criticism

Black criticism also discards the traditions of meritocracy and liberalism.... Such stories creates a wrong picture of meritocracy; every person who works hard enough can attain power, wealth, and privilege but disregarding the systemic inequalities which institutional racism offer.... Legal discourse reveals that the existing law is impartial and colorblind, nonetheless, the theory challenges this lawful “act” by scrutinizing meritocracy and liberalism as a means of self-interest, privilege and power....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

HRM & Culture - SK Holdings

The case is critically important to the formation of tenable and efficient human resources, as shall be seen in the discourse that ensues forthwith.... The issue of gender balance at the corporate level is still problematic and one that reflects the social dynamics that surround corporate or market environment....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

Critical Evaluation of the Varying Ways in Which Educational Policy Has Been Meritocratic

The paper "Critical Evaluation of the Varying Ways in Which Educational Policy Has Been Meritocratic" states that the aspect of meritocracy is apparent in the society and for every individual with the advent and implication of the policies from The Education Reform Act 1988 and Education Act 2011.... meritocracy is an idea which has been reflected through the changing policies of the education sector (Riddel, 2009).... The Acts of 1988 and 2011 are the foundation of the meritocracy in the education sector as they promote standard education and promotion of educational performance....
14 Pages (3500 words) Coursework

Chinese Higher Education in Moks Works

.... ... ... The paper "Chinese Higher Education in Works Mok, Kipnis, Yang, and Crabb" is a good example of an article on education.... Mok (2005) in his article has selected the theme riding over global capitalism and socialism so as to examine how the government of China has reinvented the delivery of its social policy through espousal of novel strategies of governance....
11 Pages (2750 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us