StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Labor Industrial Relations - Literature review Example

Summary
The paper "Labor Industrial Relations" states that by eliminating the employee’s power for arbitration and protection, the new legislation effectively strangles the employee into an almost forced work situation while it is promoted as freeing the entrepreneurial spirit in the form of contractor work. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.6% of users find it useful
Labor Industrial Relations
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Labor Industrial Relations"

Article Summary Bradon Ellem, in his article “Beyond Industrial Relations: WorkChoices and the Reshaping of Labour, Class and the Commonwealth”, argues that WorkChoices is dense and extremely complex with a profound preference for the companies and organizations rather than concern for the laborers. He starts by outlining the various ways in which this legislation has removed employee protection efforts through such measures as removing awards systems and the ‘no disadvantage test’ and limiting the power of unions and other organizations to fairly arbitrate disputes while remaining in favor of the corporation in areas such as Australian Workplace Agreements and other contractual labour restrictions. Examining the legislation more carefully, the author concedes that there are reasons to suspect that it actually represents no significant differences to the direction of older legislation. However, he also indicates that the program does represent a fundamental shift because of its national scale. This argument is supported by an examination of the problems of shared terminology by opposing viewpoints, arguments based upon the wording of the Australian Constitution and the revealed intentions of change this legislation represents. Regarding terminology, he particularly addresses the use of the term ‘deregulation’ because of its unspecific nature since every form of organization must be regulated in some form, either internally (managerial control) or externally (governmental control). Referencing the Australian Constitution, Ellem specifically points to Section 51 in which the Commonwealth was charged with the protection and arbitration of industrial workers’ rights. Expanded systems in the past have led to a situation in which curtailment of these systems is seen as a benefit, but the net effect is a significant reduction in the power of collectivism (the employees as represented by the unions) in combination with a significant expansion of the power of the organization. Finally, he indicates that these changes and arguments reveal the intended changes as being the corporatization of Australia rather than the concern for its people. Ellem further argues his case by attempting to dismiss the Government’s claims that it is merely trying to bring the industrial market into the same sphere of deregulation seen in other markets and that the nature of the worker has changed sufficiently to require new modes of management. He argues that despite the tendency to think of it as such, the labour market is different from other markets because it deals with human beings and is therefore not more efficient simply because it is deregulated. By eliminating the employee’s power for arbitration and protection, the new legislation effectively strangles the employee into an almost forced work situation while it is promoted as freeing the entrepreneurial spirit in the form of contractor work. The sources Ellem uses in his article seem to be quite valid although perhaps not used as effectively as they might be. They include several press releases and studies regarding the WorkChoices legislation as well as studies into the various issues regarding worker productivity. Academic works are used for much of the basis of the report, which brings it further credibility as these reports are written by well-respected names in the field such as J. Buchanan and John Burgess. In addition, the arguments Ellem presents are well founded upon diverse fields like economics, human psychology and management theories, reflecting the complicated subject with which it deals. Sources upon which various arguments are based are cited in the notes, but it is not possible to deduce from the small amount of detail provided about these studies whether their present use is in keeping with the overall arguments presented in the original works. Because of the fluidity with which Ellem introduces his arguments, however, it is not immediately apparent that his sources are as well-founded as they are until one takes the time to peruse the notes. With a little greater reference to the validity of his sources, Ellem would be more efficiently persuasive. The argument is strong in its theory and its sourced material, but is weak in its introduction. Founded as it is on a variety of academic and peer-reviewed studies in various fields that attempt to address the complexities of the human workers most affected by such legislation, Ellem outlines his argument in a relatively simple format that provides it yet further strength. He addresses his argument that the new legislation presents a fundamental shift in the way in which labour laws are defining society and class in Australia with a lesson in how it is different from previous legislation, how it effectively removes rights and protections from the worker and how this is changing the way in which labour laws are understood. While each of his positions are important elements of the shifts occurring in the Australian work environment, there is not sufficient space devoted to truly developing any of these points to any great detail. As a result, none of these arguments is adequately explained or understood within the context of the article for complete understanding of the issues involved. Instead, the article serves as little more than a quick, broad, general overview of the major concerns of the WorkChoice legislation, with these concerns being only tenuously linked together by a thread of common concern. Speaking for myself, I am concerned about the issues raised within the article as it exposes a serious threat to the welfare and rights of the common working class. Without governmental protection or the protective arm of the unions, the workers have few, if any, options left open to them should corporations begin abusing their power. Although it may be true that unions and other forms of arbitration may have been excessive in the past or extended into realms in which it really doesn’t belong, it is also true that corporations, left unchecked, have a tremendous tendency to abuse their privileges. This condition has been demonstrated by numerous abuses perpetrated in reality or in absentia by corporations in areas such as Asia and Africa where economies depend almost exclusively upon the patronage of a single company and therefore have very few options in demanding appropriate, humane treatment of the workers employed. These factories are seen to force children to work long hours in dangerous conditions, allow workers little if any time off and offer only subsistence or lower wages as a result of all this work. Employee protection options are essential for the operation of a free and democratic society. Employees must have adequate means of addressing corporate abuses and complaints and corporations must have an entity with sufficient power and authority to hold them in check if and when necessary to ensure that the general population, comprised mostly of the workers they hire, does not stagnate or fail as a result of the greedy and exploitive actions of the unrestrained managers. References Ellem, B. (2006), ‘Beyond Industrial Relations: WorkChoices and the Reshaping of Labour, Class and the Commonwealth’, Labour History, 90, May, pp. 211-20. Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Labor Industrial Relations

Industrial Relation in the USA

The author of the "Industrial Relation in the USA" paper discusses the statement that argues that "The industrial relations system in the United States of America is characterized by high levels of juridification and low levels of collective bargaining".... In 1970 the juridification process of US industrial relations reached a landmark with excessive government intervention in industrial relations (Logan, 2006).... The industrial relations system in the USA is characterized by high levels of juridification and low levels of collective bargaining....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

The World Trade Organization and Free Trade

Democratic Development as the Fruits of Labor, industrial relations Research Association. ... The paper "The World Trade Organization and Free Trade" states that developing economies have become integrated through the common laws and regulations that have been established through the organization, facilitating the existence of harmonious relations.... Developing economies have become integrated through the common laws and regulations that have been established through the organization, facilitating the existence of harmonious relations....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

UK Industrial Restrictions on Labour Relations

1998, Changing industrial relations in Europe, Wiley-Blackwell, ... 1998, European Union and European industrial relations: Global Challenges, National Developments and Transnational Dynamics, London: Routledge. ... UK Industrial Restrictions on Labour relations Introduction There have been critical concerns for human rights protection since the late medieval times when slavery was a central focus for political debut.... ince then, a lot has transpired in the field of human relations with respect to employment, governance as well as protection of human rights....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Industrial and Labor Relations

This report "Industrial and Labor relations" examines the various unit operations including the organizational campaigns, elections, contract negotiations, arbitrations, labor relations, and strikes in addition to how the changes in employee relations strategies impact an organization's performance.... Labor relations It is universally conceded that labor unions have served the needs of the ‘working man'but the extent to which they positively affect the overall welfare of the nation's economic structure is called into question by some, especially business leaders....
5 Pages (1250 words) Report

Industrial Relations

This paper discusses the importance of industrial relations practices, their significance in the organizations and the impact they have on the employment of labor.... Various aspects such as economic, social and industrial factors which directly affect the industrial relations.... Regardless of the difference in the industrial relations practices that exist in various organizations all over the world.... «industrial relations» ...
12 Pages (3000 words) Term Paper

Major Reforms in Australian Industrial Relations and Employment Law

This work called "Major Reforms in Australian industrial relations and Employment Law" describes the reforms in the employment sector by pointing out various benefits and poor decisions that were made in Australia for the past two decades.... Questions abound as to whether it is necessary for the State to take part in industrial relations reform and employment laws.... The past two decades have witnessed major reforms in Australian industrial relations and employment law....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

The Impact of Globalization on Recent Changes to Employment Patterns

The paper "The Impacts of Globalization on industrial relations Policies" focuses on the fact that the era of globalization or liberalization has impacted the pattern of industrial relation policies and, thereby, the employment structures of the Indian economy.... Secondly the report tends to set its focus on understanding the changes in the employment scenario in terms of patterns and structures linking the same to the aspect of industrial relations.... The project herein only focuses to study the impacts of globalization on industrial relations policies and its effects on employment structures....
16 Pages (4000 words) Report

Labour Industrial Relations

The paper 'Labour industrial relations' is a cogent example of human resources essay.... LABOR relations ………………………….... This paper will critically evaluate the potential features of labor relations to find out how joining a union will potentially benefit employees.... abor relations ... Researchers identified that organizations can positively influence the performance through skillful labor relations....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us